10 cases, when different actresses played the same heroine. And we can not decide who better coped with the role

Some stories, fictional or reality, fall in love with people that the directions are taken for their filmization again and again. Sometimes they manage to remove excellent cinema, as strong as the paintings of the predecessors. However, there is always a chance to get to come in: add inappropriate turns of the plot or take the role of an unsuitable actor. And all the efforts are rewarded only by a squall of negative from the demanding public.

We are in adme.ru compared 20+ films, in which different actresses appeared in the same roles. And we can hardly decide which of them better coped with their work. And in the bonus you will find a celebrity that will play a bright historical person in a new television series with a challenged fate.

Cinderella

© Cinderella / Lenfilm, © a Cinderella Story / Warner Bros., © Cinderella / Walt Disney Pictures

• Janina Jaimo ("Cinderella", 1947)
• Hilary Duff ("History Cinderella", 2004)
• Lily James (Cinderella, 2015)

Maria Antoinetta

© Marie-Antoinette Reine De France / Les Films Gibé, © Marie Antoinette / Columbia Pictures, © Les Adieux à La Reine / Canal +

• Michelle Morgan ("Maria Antoinette - Queen of France", 1956)
• Kirsten Dunst ("Maria-Antoinetta", 2006)
• Diana Kruger ("Goodbye, my queen", 2012)

Belle

© La Belle et La Bête / Les Films André Paulvé, © La Belle & La Bête / Pathé, © Beauty and The Beast / Walt Disney Pictures

• Jozett Day ("Beauty and the Beast", 1946)
• Leah Seida ("Beauty and the Beast", 2014)
• Emma Watson ("Beauty and Monster", 2017)

Alice

© Alice Through The Looking Glass / Channel 4 Television Corporation, © Alice Through The Looking Glass / Walt Disney Pictures, © Come Away / Ace Pictures Entertainment

• Kate Beckinsale ("Alice in the Looking Game", 1998)
• Mia Vasikovska ("Alice in Wonderland", 2010)
• Kira Chans ("Peter Peng and Alice in Wonderland", 2020)

Milady Winter

© The Three Musketeers / Mgm, © d'Artagnan and Three Musketeers / Odessa Film Studio, © The Three Musketeers / Summit Entertainment

• Lana Turner ("Three Musketeers", 1948)
• Margarita Terekhova ("D'Artagnan and Three Musketeers", 1978)
• Milla Yovovich ("Musketeers", 2011)

Constance

© The Three Musketeers / Mgm, © d'Artagnan and Three Musketeers / Odessa Film Studio, © The Three Musketeers / Summit Entertainment

• Jun Ellison ("Three Musketeers", 1948)
• Irina Alferova ("D'Artagnan and Three Musketeers", 1978)
• Gabriella Wilde ("Musketeers", 2011)

Mortish Addams.

© The Addams Family / Filmways Television, © The AdDams Family / Paramount Pictures, © The New Addams Family / Saban International

• Carolyn Jones (Series "Family Addams", 1964-1966)
• Angelica Houston ("Family Addams", 1991)
• Ellie Harvey (TV series "New Family Addams", 1998-1999)

Catherine Ernsho.

© Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights / Paramount Pictures, © Wuthering Heights / Mammoth Screen, © Wuthering Heights / Ecosse Films

• Juliette Binoash ("Thunderstorm Pass", 1992)
• Charlotte Riley (Mini-Series "Thunderstorm Pass", 2009)
• Kaya Skodelirio ("Thunderstorm Pass", 2011)

Marilyn Monroe

© The Mystery of Natalie Wood / Abc, © My Week With Marilyn / BBC Films, © Blonde / Plan b Entertainment

• Sophie Monk (mini-series "Mystery Natalie Wood", 2004)
• Michelle Williams ("7 days and nights with Marilyn", 2011)
• Ana de Armaas ("Blonde", 2021)

Bonus: Anna Boleyn

© The Other Boleyn Girl / BBC Films, © The Tudors / Showtime, © Jodiesmith / Instagram

• Natalie Dormer (TV series "Tudora", 2007-2010)
• Natalie Portman ("Even one of the kind of pain", 2008)
• Jody Terner-Smith (TV series "Anna Boleyn", 2021)

What do you think, who of the actresses most convincingly coped with his role? And who are you, on the contrary, would they be replaced?